Resolving a performance concern through an informal conversation

This anonymised historical HR case shows how a proportionate informal conversation helped an employer address a performance concern and create a clear route for follow-up. The advisory work was delivered before Employee Passport Limited was formed. The organisation, employee and adviser are not identified. The source record does not establish a sector or location, so this case is not presented as evidence for either.
The employer question
The employer reported that an employee was not completing expected duties and that colleagues were having to pick up the work. The concern needed attention, but the record did not indicate that the employer had already tested the issue through a clear informal conversation.
The practical question was whether the manager could start informally, while keeping a fair route to a formal process if performance did not improve.
The work delivered
The adviser recommended that the manager first hold a private, structured conversation with the employee. The manager could describe the work that was not being completed, explain the expected standard, listen to the employee’s response and agree what needed to happen next.
The advice also preserved the employer’s options. If the informal step did not lead to sufficient improvement, or if the facts indicated a more serious issue, the employer could consider its formal performance or disciplinary procedure. The client confirmed that the manager would speak with the employee, and the adviser followed up afterwards.
The recorded result
The later client update recorded that no further action was needed. This is a narrow, dated, client-reported outcome from the historical case record. It confirms the position reported at follow-up; it does not prove a permanent improvement, quantify a productivity gain or establish that no later concerns arose.
That distinction matters in a genuine case study. The record supports the intervention and the conclusion reported at the time. It does not support broader claims about the organisation, location, sector or long-term effects.
What managers can take from this case
- Describe the concern precisely. Use examples of the work, deadline or standard involved instead of relying on labels such as “poor attitude”.
- Give the employee a fair chance to respond. A conversation may reveal unclear instructions, training needs, workload issues, health concerns or another explanation that needs consideration.
- State the expected standard. The employee should understand what needs to change, who can help and when progress will be reviewed.
- Record the essentials. Keep a confidential note of the concern, the employee’s response, support offered, agreed actions and review point.
- Escalate proportionately. Use the relevant formal procedure if the matter is serious, remains unresolved or the agreed improvement is not achieved.
Informal performance conversation worksheet
| Manager prompt | Record |
|---|---|
| What work or standard is causing concern? | _____ |
| What examples and dates can be discussed? | _____ |
| What explanation or context did the employee give? | _____ |
| What support, training or clarification is needed? | _____ |
| What action and standard were agreed? | _____ |
| When will progress be reviewed? | _____ |
| What happens if the concern continues? | _____ |
Fair process still matters
Acas advises employers to support improvement before moving to dismissal and to follow a fair procedure. The right approach depends on the facts, the seriousness of the concern, the employee’s explanation and any relevant policy or contractual terms.
- Acas: problems with an employee’s performance
- EPL: coaching before disciplinary action
- Outsourced HR support
- Contact EPL
Need a proportionate first step for a performance concern? Talk to EPL before choosing the next action.
Editorial review: EPL HR team. The historical case record was reviewed and anonymised for publication on 16 November 2026. The featured image is illustrative and does not depict the client, employee or adviser.

